Mining and Resources center

Advertisements

A platinum basket?

Font Scale:
16 May 2008 @ 07:48 am EST
  • Print
  • E-Mail

Theremay be some 60 listed stocks (see below) that offer direct or indirect exposureto platinum group metals (PGMs), from early stage explorers to fully fledgedproducers, but recent portfolio flow trends indicate that it's the more maturenames that have investors flocking in once again.  

Interms of price performance, relative to other mining sub-sectors, listedplatinum stocks currently rank fifth, after potash, iron ore, coal and majorminers. To that extent at least, platinum stocks are outperforming gold andsilver stocks. This is line with at least some prevailing sentiment in theprofessional research community.

Ina recent commodity and energy strategy note, the Bank Credit Analystrecommended that investors should buy a basket of platinum producer equities;that they should wait to buy platinum outright, and to stay long (bullish)platinum versus palladium (platinum's main sister metal, ahead of rhodium).  

Bothplatinum and rhodium have traded up to record levels in the past few months;the advance of palladium was less impressive. Around 80% of the world's PGMsare mined out of southern Africa, but Russia's giant Norilsk (NILSY US, USD 29.90 ashare) polymetallic complex ranks as the single biggest palladium producerglobally.

AsBCA Research reminds, the fundamental demand/supply imbalance for platinum isnot controversial. The latest big chunk of evidence on supply bottlenecks camewith Anglo Platinum (AMS SJ, ZAR 1,370.00) recently announcing that powershortages knocked down its platinum output by 19% in the first quarter of 2008.BCA Research adds that there is "not much chance of diesel autocatalystsubstitution over the next year".

WhileUS monetary conditions are seen as remaining generous for the rest of the year,a very good slice of this is seen as "in the price" of currency, money andprecious metal markets. Gold and silver futures are seen as high-beta plays;for platinum, price appears to be the main issue.  

Theprice of platinum impresses alongside its moving averages, despite theunprecedented pace in the recent uptrend. Net speculative positions in platinumremain high, but on the potential downside, jewellery-related demand forplatinum could be undermined.

Meanwhile,in notes from the RBC Capital Markets inaugural PGM conference held in Londonon Friday, analyst Leon Esterhuizen said: "We are dealing with an industry indistress. While the world needs more platinum the producers are being preventedfrom delivering by challenges such as restricted electrical power supply,limited and shrinking skills pool and sharply increasing capital and operatingcosts.   

"Howeverjunior companies who are able to succeed in this climate and capitalise on thevery high metal prices will potentially become prime take-over targets forlarger companies, enabling them to break into the select group of only ahandful of major global PGM producers.  The race is on!"

However,a glance at the pricing of junior PGM stocks indicates but slim investorinterest. A sampling of more than 40 stocks in this broad category shows thatprices are currently trading more than 40% off highs. Even in the Tier IIlisted PGM category, it is only really Aquarius (AQP LN, GBP 8.41) and Northam(NHM SJ, ZAR 72.00) that appear to be exciting investors.

Selected platinum stocks

Stock

From

From

Value

price

high*

low*

US$m

Tier I platinum

Anglo Platinum

ZAR 1,370.00

-0.7%

68.1%

42590

Impala

ZAR 345.00

-6.3%

100.6%

28610

Lonmin

GBP 34.36

-21.9%

25.6%

10462

Averages/total

-9.6%

64.7%

81662

Weighted averages

-5.9%

70.4%

Diversified

Anglo American

GBP 35.80

-2.7%

65.2%

93744

Mvela Resources

ZAR 63.20

-8.4%

58.4%

1754

Norilsk

USD 29.90

-10.7%

69.4%

56998

ARM

ZAR 276.80

-2.5%

26.2%

7687

Averages/total

-6.1%

54.8%

160183

Weighted averages

-5.8%

64.1%

Tier II platinum

Stillwater

USD 13.61

-40.1%

83.4%

1263

Aquarius

GBP 8.41

-7.1%

104.8%

4207

Northam

ZAR 72.00

-9.8%

89.5%

2256

NA Palladium

CAD 6.44

-50.3%

98.2%

510

Zimplats

AUD 14.00

-22.2%

75.0%

1414

Eastplats

CAD 3.07

-26.6%

57.4%

2061

Anooraq

CAD 3.08

-42.8%

41.3%

563

Averages/total

-28.4%

78.5%

12274

Weighted averages

-22.2%

83.0%

Developers and explorers

Eurasia Mining

GBP 0.04

-32.6%

31.8%

997

Platmin

CAD 6.80

-40.0%

23.4%

745

Wesizwe

ZAR 8.20

-41.0%

26.2%

598

Aquiline

CAD 8.15

-33.5%

25.2%

482

Pt Australia

AUD 2.38

-22.0%

64.1%

463

Polymet Mining

CAD 3.77

-16.0%

83.9%

507

Sylvania

GBP 1.06

-32.1%

35.0%

367

Starfield

CAD 0.90

-53.4%

28.6%

284

Ridge

GBP 1.31

-21.6%

63.8%

232

PGM

CAD 2.45

-47.8%

11.9%

150

Solitario

CAD 5.40

-10.7%

22.7%

157

Jubilee

GBP 0.82

-36.2%

39.4%

138

Nkwe

AUD 0.88

-30.7%

29.4%

153

Braemore

GBP 0.09

-62.9%

33.3%

118

Marathon

CAD 3.70

-55.2%

8.8%

95

Caledonia

CAD 0.17

-25.0%

65.0%

81

Freegold Venture

CAD 1.12

-58.5%

28.7%

70

Franconia

CAD 1.67

-60.2%

45.2%

95

Cons. Puma

CAD 1.24

-44.6%

7.8%

63

Avalon Ventures

CAD 1.61

-31.2%

78.9%

102

Rusina

AUD 0.26

-66.2%

36.8%

59

Largo Resources

CAD 0.58

-38.3%

70.6%

66

Macdonald Mines

CAD 0.36

-72.7%

500.0%

49

Hard Creek

CAD 0.76

-70.8%

35.7%

45

Birch Mountain

CAD 0.49

-88.3%

22.5%

41

MetalCORP

CAD 0.51

-72.7%

5.2%

22

Wallbridge

CAD 0.39

-46.6%

56.0%

34

Benton

CAD 0.52

-75.8%

30.0%

35

Mustang Minerals

CAD 0.50

-62.1%

38.9%

36

Northern Shield

CAD 0.58

-52.5%

110.9%

30

Platina

AUD 0.48

-73.5%

3.2%

20

Darnley Bay

CAD 0.38

-51.3%

72.7%

18

Pacific NW Cap.

CAD 0.30

-62.5%

7.1%

18

Niplats

AUD 0.32

-80.0%

68.4%

20

Starcore

CAD 0.27

-69.7%

3.8%

16

Huston Lake

CAD 0.64

-42.9%

82.9%

17

Goldplat

GBP 0.14

-30.4%

71.9%

15

Beartooth

CAD 0.08

-59.0%

14.3%

13

Pan Palladium

AUD 0.12

-61.3%

53.8%

15

Premium Exp.

CAD 0.36

-52.0%

50.0%

13

Silvermet

CAD 0.14

-74.5%

35.0%

10

Minerva

GBP 0.04

-54.8%

3.7%

8

Hinterland Metal

CAD 0.10

-62.0%

35.7%

4

Developer averages/total

-50.6%

50.3%

6501

Weighted averages

-42.2%

36.7%

Overall averages/total

-42.6%

54.8%

260619

Overall weighted averages

-8.2%

66.0%

* 12-month

Source: data from Bloomberg; table compiled by Barry Sergeant

Advertisements

Charts

Advertisements

advertisement
 
IBTimes.com Web
Partners
International Business Times© 2008 The Ibtimes Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms of service | Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us | Contact Us | Archives
Feedback Form