Log in to your IBTimes Account

close
ID
Password

BankAtlantic sues analyst, claiming defamation



By EILEEN AJ CONNELLY, AP
21 July 2008 @ 06:28 pm EST

NEW YORK - Regional bank BankAtlantic Bancorp filed suit Monday against well-known banking analyst Richard Bove and his firm, charging both with defamation and negligence for mentioning the company in a list of banks that might fail.

Related Topic

Get stories by e-mail on this topic.

E-mail:
Quotes
BBX 1.35 -0.05
BFF 0.5 -0.04

SYMBOL LOOKUP

Fort Lauderdale, Fla.-based BankAtlantic filed suit in the state court for Broward County, Fla., against Bove and Ladenburg Thalmann, citing a July 13 research note that asked the question "Who is Next?" following the failure of IndyMac Bancorp.

Bove, based in Lutz, Fla., used two different methods to come up with lists of "who the next failure is." The first examined the non-performing assets of the bank and divided them by its outstanding loans. Bove said a ratio above 5 percent suggested danger. BankAtlantic Bancorp Inc. was 10th on his list, with a ratio of 4.4 percent.

The second method divided non-performing assets by the institution's reserves-plus-common-equity, and said a ratio above 40 percent put the institution in "the danger zone." Using this method, BankAtlantic was 12th on Bove's list, with a ratio of 38.4 percent.

BankAtlantic's shares fell 30 cents, or 25 percent, to close at 90 cents on July 14, the first trading day after Bove's report was released. The stock has since recovered, and rose 21 cents, or 12.5 percent, to close at $1.89 Monday.

A spokeswoman said upon advice of his attorney, Bove had no response. Paul Caminit, a spokesman for Ladenburg Thalmann said, "We'll defend ourselves against this meritless lawsuit."

Highly ranked by several different outlets, Bove's commentary is frequently quoted in the financial press. He distributes his reports on banking companies widely, and is known as a contrarian for views that frequently tack differently than many on Wall Street.

But BankAtlantic maintained the methodology Bove used was flawed. It claims it is well capitalized, its ratio of non-performing loans to total loans is 1.25 percent and its ratio of non-performing loans to its capital and reserves is 12.5 percent. Using Bove's parameters for his "danger zone," BankAtlantic maintained its "numbers are not even close."

"The problem is that, while Bove's report purports to consider which banks might fail, he failed to examine the health of the banks and thrifts in his report," the company said in a statement. "Instead, he only examined holding company data which, in at least our case, is meaningless information. This is simply shocking."

BankAtlantic maintained only the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. had sufficient data to judge whether any institution was in danger of failing, and in its own case, the data Bove used was that of its two holding companies, BankAtlantic Bancorp and BFC Financial Corp., which "contain other assets and business lines which make the comparison nonsensical."

Copyright 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

    Click!
  • Rate this article:

Comments

Post Your Comment

You must be an IBTimes member to post a comment. Login | Register



advertisement
More Industries
The soaring cost of steel has Toyota considering raising prices in Japan without a model makeover for the first time in three decades, the Japanese autom...
Support for climate-change proposals may be growing among investors in big U.S. companies. Shareholder resolutions related to climate change more than do...
As Ford Motor Co. faces perhaps the most difficult period in its 105-year history, the company is trying to boost employee confidence by showing them--an...

Advertisement
Corporate Website Design

Professional Website Design For Corporate - Get a Free Quote Today

advertisement
 
IBTimes.com Web
Partners
International Business Times© 2008 The Ibtimes Company. All Rights Reserved. Terms of service | Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us | Contact Us | Archives