By William Rees Mogg
Not every boom becomes a bubble, writes William Rees Mogg for The Daily Reckoning, and not every boom ends in a bust.
But most of them do. In the present economic situation, we need to be careful to distinguish between the two types of rapid price increase.
In the United States and United Kingdom, it is clear that the housing boom has been a bubble. In the US, the bubble has already burst the only question is when the US housing market will reach its low point.
Britain is following the same track, but is somewhere between six and twelve months behind, as well as being significantly more inflated at the top.
There are some important differences between the two markets. For most purposes, the British housing market can be regarded as a single market. There are, of course, regional variations which largely reflect the distance from London the Inverness market fluctuates in a different cycle from London. But, over time all the regional markets tend to move in a similar rhythm.
In the United States, the regional differences have been much more important. The housing bubble, which is now receding, is the first nationwide housing bubble in American history. In the past, Americans have been drawn into local or regional housing booms, like the great Florida boom of the 1920s. This time the US boom ran throughout the States.
I think the cause must have been the universality of cheap credit, the same influence as created the boom in hedge funds and private equity. If the availability of credit is the chief determinant of house prices, then Florida and Chicago are likely to share in both the boom and recession. Regional differences become secondary influences, as they are in the stock market.
The fall in the housing market has wiped out very important assets of the banking system, leading to the collapses of Bear Stearns and Northern Rock and the distress of other lenders. It is difficult to put a figure on the contraction of credit that has resulted. The International Monetary Fund has suggested $1 trillion, which is an impressive round number. (Then again, the IMF Is Selling Gold to cover its own budget deficit...)
What has actually been lost is a multiple of the fall in house values, since there is a multiplier effect on credit and on the willingness to lend. A bank which has lost a billion dollars in the housing market (or some derivative of the housing market) will feel itself to be short of capital, and so will seek to draw in as much cash as it can.
It may well go from over generous lending to exaggerated borrowing, which will take it from being a net lender to being a net borrower. This banking squeeze is pronounced both in the US and the UK.
However, there are other global price rises which are not bubbles. The oil market has risen to record highs, with Brent Crude the European benchmark at around $108 a barrel. Gold Prices have broken through $1,000 ounce, if only for a few days before falling back to retrench nearer $900 per ounce.
These surges cannot be merely a reflection of excess liquidity, since both the oil price and Gold Market have continued to rise at a time when credit was becoming much scarcer. In the case of oil there are non monetary reasons for higher prices, including the high level of demand from Asia, the geopolitical risks of dependence on Iran and the physical loss of production in Iraq.
(Gold's continued bull market, on the other hand, while related to falling mining supply, is clearly built on fears over the value and quality of official fiat currency.)
The rise in oil prices extends to rises in products dependant on oil, particularly foodstuffs. There is a global increase of grain prices, causing most suffering in Africa and in the less developed Asian countries. These are not speculative increases, but are reflections of real economic and political factors.
I do not believe that the world is on the edge of another Great Slump, but the combination of the deflationary effect of the collapse of a widespread housing bubble with the inflationary effect of higher prices for oil and food does present Governments with the most difficult economic problems since the 1970s. It was then called stagflation , to reflect stagnant inflation.
Both horns of the stagflation dilemma now look sharp and threatening.
What goes up when interest rates fall, inflation rises, and savers get squeezed in the middle? For a detailed report on How the Gold Market Really Works, click here to Register with BullionVault now...
Leading political editor William Rees Mogg is former editor in chief for The Times of London and an independent peer in the House of Lords in Westminster. Lord Rees Mogg has been credited with accurately forecasting glasnost and the fall of the Berlin Wall as well as the 1987 financial crash. His political commentary appears in The Times every Monday. His financial insights can be found in Strategic Investment, the widely respected newsletter he founded more than 15 years ago.
By arrangement with: www.bullionvault.com