Florida Gay Threesome Arrest: Bradenton Man 'Paranoid With Trust Issues' Dents Boyfriend's Car After Sex Act

A gay Florida man was arrested on domestic assault charges after he allegedly got into an argument with his boyfriend when he developed trust issues following a threesome.

Johnny Anderson, 23, of Bradenton, Fla., allegedly punched a hole in the sheet rock of the home he shares with boyfriend Adam Cole and then punched Cole’s car glass window Thursday, according to a Manatee County Sheriff’s Office report obtained by the Smoking Gun.

Cole, 23, told a sheriff’s deputy that he and Anderson engaged in a threesome earlier in the day and that Anderson “became paranoid with trust issues.” Anderson later told authorities that his boyfriend cheated on him three times but that he’s forgiven his partner.

Anderson then “became irate” and punched a hole in the sheet rock and blocked Cole from leaving the home, according to the report. When Cole got in his car to leave, Anderson “became more upset and irate” and punched the car glass window, “almost breaking it and dented his door from punching so hard.”

Cole said he feared for his safety and dialed 911.

When a sheriff’s deputy arrived, the officer observed that Anderson “was very upset and crying.” Anderson allegedly told the deputy, “f--- I was upset I punched his car window I was not going to hurt him. I love him but her [sic] cheated on me three times and I forgive him.”

Anderson was arrested on domestic assault charges and taken to the Port Manatee jail, according to the incident report.

Join the Discussion