Playing the Gold, Silver Equities Selloff: Stephen Taylor
Source: Brian Sylvester of The Gold Report (3/5/12)
The precious metals equities selloff at the end of 2011 was overdone, says Stephen Taylor, portfolio manager of The Taylor Fund and founder of Taylor Asset Management, in this exclusive interview with The Gold Report. Taylor remains bullish on gold, silver and base metals and is looking to some names that were walloped in the selloff to prosper in the next three years.
The Gold Report: The Global and Mail reported that more than 50 private-equity mining deals were struck in Canada in 2011-more than in any other sector. Why is private equity pouring venture capital into junior mining plays faster than any other Canadian business sector?
Stephen Taylor: The important thing is that private equity funds have the patience and the experience to take the long-term view that's required with development-stage mining companies. There's been a growing dysfunction in the U.S. initial public offering market for small-cap companies and development-stage enterprises of any type. It has led to depressed valuations. It's not surprising that managers of private equity funds have the patience and see some bargains and are jumping into the sector.
TGR: Most of the deals involved minority positions, not takeovers. Why?
ST: That is really the best way to do deals as a private equity investor. These firms are looking to partner with or back experienced management teams. Experienced management teams are increasingly reluctant to cede control to an outside firm that doesn't have real expertise in the mining sector. Trying to seek majority control would be a mistake.
TGR: What was the performance of The Taylor Fund in 2011?
ST: The fund, which has about $45 million under management, had a rough year. It was down about 20% in 2011 after a gain of 21% in 2010 and 96% in 2009. Since inception, it's averaged just more than 26% a year versus about 9% a year for the S&P 500.
TGR: What's the current industry weighting of the fund?
ST: It's about 40% invested in energy, which is mainly oil and gas. Mining comprises about 30%. About one-third of the companies are in China, another third are in the U.S. and the final third are in Canada. The Canadian component includes many companies that have substantial operations in other parts of the world.
TGR: You previously told The Gold Report that you saw some overdone selloffs in the resource space. Was the selloff that occurred in the latter half of 2011 overdone?
ST: It clearly was. It seemed that 2011 was particularly fierce in the junior resource space. Sharp selloffs have been followed by quick bounce-backs. Miranda Gold Corp. (MAD:TSX.V) sunk from $0.67/share to $0.24/share at year-end but has since recovered somewhat. Silvermex Resources Inc. (SLX:TSX; GGCRF:OTC) went from about $1/share to $0.36/share at year-end, but is back up to $0.46/share.
TGR: Did the Taylor Fund add to existing positions or new positions as other investors were exiting junior mining plays?
ST: We were indeed. We were selective buyers on our core positions like Lumina Copper Corp. (LCC:TSX). We participated in the recent Anfield Nickel Corp. (ANF:TSX.V) financing. We want to be selective in our new additions, but we're always going to be looking to quality management teams as one of our first conditions.
TGR: How long on average do you hold a position in junior mining?
ST: Typically, two to three years. Last year, we did lighten up in some names where the results weren't what we had hoped. We lightened a bit on Fire River Gold Corp. (FAU:TSX.V; FVGCF:OTCQX) after some disappointing results.
TGR: You remain bullish on precious metals in general?
ST: As long as central governments around the world continue to print money and to telegraph a low to negative real interest-rate policy, precious metals are the place to be quite frankly. The next two quarters may be flat to sideways, but over the next two to three years precious metals are going much higher.
TGR: News about the Greek debt deal pushed the gold price up recently. Was this just a short-term uptick?
ST: The Greek debt deal is the first of many as other countries around the world will ultimately be forced to restructure their obligations as well. All of these will contribute to rising demand for precious metals and will support higher prices. It could occur in the next quarter or the next year, but I won't be so bold as to make that distinction. I do know I want to be long on precious metals and that they're going to be much higher over the course of several years.
TGR: Anfield and Lumina are nickel and copper plays. Do you see value in base metals?
ST: I do. There's a long-term secular rise in living standards that will continue for a huge portion of the world's population in China, India and Brazil. As this process grinds forward over the next 10-30 years, regardless of short-term disruptions, there will be an inevitable increase in demand for base metals. Existing deposits also continue to be depleted. As owners of some of the largest undeveloped base metals projects in the world, Anfield and Lumina are going to be well positioned.
Lumina is one of many Ross Beaty-related companies with which we've been involved. He has a tremendous record at generating shareholder value. The company has done extensive drilling on the Taca Taca property in Argentina during the past couple of years. There has also been significant historic drilling done on the project. The deposit just gets bigger and bigger. It's close to being the largest undeveloped copper deposit in the world, if it's not already.
That's going to be a very valuable resource to someone. The company has indicated that it's going to put itself up for auction at some point in the next several months. Based on transaction prices for other undeveloped copper deposits, the ultimate sale price could be in the neighborhood of $1 billion, or about $20/share. I think Lumina will be acquired or bought out in 2012 at a price in excess of $20/share.
TGR: David Strang, who is president and CEO of Lumina, was also involved in the management teams of Global Copper, Northern Peru Copper, Lumina Resources and Regalito Copper, all of which were bought by bigger players. How long before Lumina gets a takeover bid?
ST: Within the next 6 to 12 months. It's possible that an unsolicited, unexpected bid could emerge before then, but I believe the company will begin to actively solicit bids in the first half of 2012.
TGR: What does Lumina need to do before that happens?
ST: It just needs to continue to derisk the project. The largest elements have been done. Frankly, the deposit is so big at this point that I almost wish the company would explore creating a spin-off vehicle to hold a portion of it for further exploration and perhaps to sell down the road.
TGR: It's an interesting story because it's less than 100 kilometers from the Escondida Copper Mine owned and operated by BHP Billiton Ltd. (BHP: NYSE, BLT: LON, BHP:ASX) and Rio Tinto Plc (RIO:LSE). That certainly seems like a likely dance partner.
Anfield, which has essentially the same management group as Lumina, has a nickel laterite project in Guatemala. Anfield was assembled by Ross Beaty years ago and seems to work pretty well. Is Anfield a takeover target as well?
ST: I believe it is. This team has skin in the game. They have substantial personal investments in these companies. They also participated in the recent financing. As a side note, they also participated in the Lumina financing in November. I really respect that. It sends a very positive signal when management teams put up their own money and buy at prices that are close to what other investors paid.
TGR: What are some of the companies that you have positions in that are developing precious metals projects?
ST: We continue to be fans of Miranda. It has a number of irons in the fire and, ultimately, one or more of them are going to hit. It did a joint venture with Red Eagle Mining Corp. (RD:TSX.V) on the Pavo Real project in Colombia. I wouldn't be surprised if Miranda continues to pick up projects in Colombia and elsewhere.
Red Eagle continues to drill Pavo Real. It has been able to attract some sophisticated, smart investors. I've heard that Ross Beaty and his group have a position slightly less than 10% in Red Eagle. That speaks volumes as to the quality of the group that Ken Cunningham, CEO of Miranda, and Ian Slater, CEO of Red Eagle, put together.
TGR: Red Eagle has two main projects, Pavo Real and Santa Rosa. Which one of those excites you more?
ST: The drill results from Santa Rosa were OK. Clearly, one hopes for a homerun. The potential for those in a place like Colombia always exists. However, I don't play favorites. I will stand by the management team and not play geologist today.
TGR: You weren't overwhelmed by the drill results from Santa Rosa?
ST: Don't get me wrong. I was not disappointed by the Santa Rosa results. It's just that I'd love to see a homerun and this was double.
TGR: Do you think it's starting to look like a bulk tonnage target?
ST: It's always a possibility. The company didn't have any preconceptions. The point of the drilling program was to see what it had and which direction that would take it. It's got some good potential there. Let's see where the drill bit takes us.
TGR: Miranda has projects in Colombia, Nevada and Alaska. Which one is getting the lion's share of the attention?
ST: It has good joint venture partners that are busy drilling away in Nevada, one of which is Agnico-Eagle Mines Ltd. (AEM:TSX; AEM:NYSE). But the attention going forward in terms of new developments could be additional land in Colombia. CEO Cunningham clearly has his eyes and ears open. It wouldn't surprise me to see the company pick up some additional property there.
TGR: You mentioned Silvermex earlier. What are your thoughts on it?
ST: Silvermex continues to do a good job ramping up production at La Guitarra. It's slow and steady. Its stock got caught in the selloff that we talked about earlier, but it's trudging along.
I'm very bullish on silver. I believe that could outperform gold on a percentage basis over the next two to three years. Silvermex is a great way to play that trend.
TGR: What's the next catalyst for that stock?
ST: It's going to be either the silver price and the macro developments that drive that or further delineation of its plans going forward at La Guitarra. Silvermex is getting some good drill results in some high-grade areas. Everyone's waiting to see where it wants to go.
TGR: Does Pan American Silver Corp.'s (PAA:TSX; PAAS:NASDAQ) purchase of Minefinders Corp. (MFL:TSX; MFN:NYSE) bode well for a company like Silvermex?
ST: Clearly, Silvermex could be a good acquisition target at some point. It's a process that will continue into the years ahead, however.
TGR: You also have a position in Largo Resources Ltd. (LGO:TSX.V)?
ST: We have a small position. We like CEO Mark Brennan, Largo and vanadium. It had to do a bit of a dilutive financing to get its mine under construction. We may invest more in that name at some point, but we're largely on the sidelines at the moment.
TGR: Do you have any final thoughts on the space for investors?
ST: My biggest worry for a lot of these development-stage companies is governmental risk. Governments and jurisdictions around the world may get greedy when faced with the pressure to restructure their financial obligations and debt. They may attempt to take a bigger piece of the pie. That's a risk that's always been part of the mining business, but investors should be particularly attuned to that over the next two to three years.
Stephen Taylor is chairman and CEO of Taylor Asset Management, a Chicago-based investment management firm focusing on small-cap domestic equities and emerging markets. He also serves as a portfolio manager for the Taylor International Fund Ltd., a small-cap equity fund. In addition to emerging markets, Taylor's area of expertise includes private equity, restructuring and turnaround situations and both small- and mid-cap companies. He has considerable experience in the natural resources and finance industries in Canada and China.
Want to read more exclusive Gold Report interviews like this? Sign up for our free e-newsletter, and you'll learn when new articles have been published. To see a list of recent interviews with industry analysts and commentators, visit our Exclusive Interviews page.
1) Brian Sylvester of The Gold Report conducted this interview. He personally and/or his family own shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: None.
2) The following companies mentioned in the interview are sponsors of The Gold Report: Red Eagle Mining Corp., Silvermex Resources Inc., Minefinders Corp. Streetwise does not accept stock in exchange for services.
3) Stephen Taylor: I personally and/or my family own shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: Lumina Copper Corp., Anfield Nickel Corp., Largo Resources Ltd., Miranda Gold Corp., Silvermex Resources Inc., Fire River Gold Corp., Red Eagle Mining Corp. I personally and/or my family am paid by the following companies mentioned in this interview: None. I was not paid by Streetwise for participating in this story.
Streetwise - The Gold Report is Copyright © 2012 by Streetwise Reports LLC. All rights are reserved. Streetwise Reports LLC hereby grants an unrestricted license to use or disseminate this copyrighted material (i) only in whole (and always including this disclaimer), but (ii) never in part.
The Gold Report does not render general or specific investment advice and does not endorse or recommend the business, products, services or securities of any industry or company mentioned in this report.
From time to time, Streetwise Reports LLC and its directors, officers, employees or members of their families, as well as persons interviewed for articles on the site, may have a long or short position in securities mentioned and may make purchases and/or sales of those securities in the open market or otherwise.
Streetwise Reports LLC does not guarantee the accuracy or thoroughness of the information reported.
Streetwise Reports LLC receives a fee from companies that are listed on the home page in the In This Issue section. Their sponsor pages may be considered advertising for the purposes of 18 U.S.C. 1734.
Participating companies provide the logos used in The Gold Report. These logos are trademarks and are the property of the individual companies.
101 Second St., Suite 110
Petaluma, CA 94952
Tel.: (707) 981-8999
Fax: (707) 981-8998