Ross Beaty: Gold, Silver, Copper, Nickel and Alternative Energy for Fun and Profit
Source: Karen Roche and JT Long of The Gold Report (10/12/11)
Legendary mining entrepreneur Ross Beaty is an optimist. He likes the opportunities present in both bear and bull markets. In this exclusive interview with The Gold Report at the Casey Research Summit in Phoenix, he explains his love of metals and alternative energy and what he is doing to position himself regardless of where the markets go.
COMPANIES MENTIONED: ALTERRA POWER CORP. - KEEGAN RESOURCES INC. - PAN AMERICAN SILVER CORP.
The Gold Report: Your talk was titled Gold, Silver, Copper, Nickel and Alternative Energy: the Commodities I Still Like. Before we get into the specific commodities, I wanted to ask you about the distortions in supply and demand that you mentioned. As more investment is going into exploration, fewer discoveries are being made. Is that because the easy ones have already been mined? Are costs higher? Are there more regulatory burdens? And how does that impact share prices?
Ross Beaty: It is more expensive to discover resources because there are more barriers to development; there are more empowered people who don't want a mine in their back yard. The U.S. is a perfect example where there are some great ore bodies that simply are not allowed to be developed. What used to take three years now takes 10 or 20. That means that supply just can't respond quickly enough to rises in prices and prices stay higher longer.
Share prices are influenced by many factors-perceptions about long-term and short-term trends. The winds of change that affect profitability of a mine in a particular place present a very complicated picture. You have to look at operating and capital costs. If you work anywhere other than the U.S., in Chile for example where the currency has increased in value 30% against the dollar in the last three years, you have to consider the impact of the devalued dollar because suddenly all local costs have gone up 30%. All of this weighs on profitability. It is difficult to break out the impact of just the price of development alone on share price, but it does have an impact.
You also have to realize that exploration and mining companies are very different. Exploration companies won't have cash flow for many years. It's a much riskier business to evaluate compared to a mining company that suffers changes in revenue and costs minute by minute. For example, one of my companies, Pan American Silver Corp. (PAA:TSX; PAAS:NASDAQ), the second-largest primary silver producer in the world, produces 24 million ounces of silver each year. If we have a silver price change of year-on-year $10/ounce, that immediately translates into an extra $240 million (M) of cash flow. If I have a deposit in the ground that will take 10 years to dig out, short-term price fluctuations mean absolutely nothing to the profitability of the company. It's a very different thing.
TGR: Do people have longer-term investing strategies toward exploration stocks if it takes so long to pay off?
RB: It always surprises me that people treat exploration stocks as if they were producing mining companies. Share prices go up and down based on the price of the metal. It makes no sense, but they do. They also judge the immediate value of an exploration company based on political changes when often the political situation will have changed completely by the time the mine is producing in five or ten years.
TGR: Does politics play an important role in the profitability of producing mining companies?
RB: Politics have greater impact on producing companies. We have an asset in Bolivia. In May, the president made a sweeping statement that he wanted to nationalize the mining industry. Pan American was hit by 15% share price drop overnight even though nothing happened, the rules didn't change, the mine is still operating. And that mine is only about 6% of the net asset value of our company anyway. Investors sell on rumors. That is the world we live in.
TGR: Once a mining company finds a resource and gets through the long permitting process, is it difficult to find qualified people?
RB: The existence of a trained workforce-engineers and geologists-is a very serious problem today. Not enough are being educated. The same is true in the oil industry. Keep your bankers and lawyers, but send us your engineers and geologists. It's the same in Peru, Argentina and Chile. That will impact how long it takes to get a mine built, how well it is built and how profitable it will be in the end. It is a very serious problem.
TGR: Is there a solution?
RB: There is a lag and often it ends up countercyclical. When the market is up, students go in, but it takes four years and by then the market could be down. I have seen this many times, but this particular construction boom is just sucking up everyone. We need more people going into these programs.
TGR: You said gold has great legs. How high can it go?
RB: I have no idea. I just know the forces driving metal prices are very strong right now. Gold is in a secular bull market with long-term upswing driven by governments printing money, lack of supply and increased demand from China. These are powerful forces. When they will stop, I don't know, but I don't see things changing anytime soon. That is especially good for gold and silver.
TGR: You sold Ventana Gold Corp. (VEN:TSX) last year for $1.5 billion. Now you are an investor inKeegan Resources Inc. (KGN:TSX; KGN:NYSE.A). Is that the same business model: explore, derisk and sell?
RB: I like the story. Keegan is basically the same business model as Ventana. The company is developing a gold deposit in Ghana. It hopes to sell it and that usually commands a premium. It could take a month or it could take three years. My money is on the shorter term.
TGR: You called silver the schizoid metal because it doesn't know if it is a precious metal, an industrial metal or an investment insurance play and that can make it more volatile. Are ETFs bringing more investors and therefore making it even more volatile?
RB: The silver ETF has been the most important thing driving silver prices in history. It has created a whole new demand from people who want an easy way to buy physical silver.
TGR: Is it a new demand or does it cannibalize the equities?
RB: It definitely cannibalizes equities, so does the gold ETF. But I would rather have a higher silver price since that provides better cash generation and a more sustainable long-term business. They are both good ways to have exposure to silver. I was a big part of the establishment of the silver ETF and without a doubt that has profoundly contributed to the rise in silver prices.
TGR: Is that also true on the gold side?
RB: Not as much on the gold side. Silver is a much thinner market so a little bit of money on the silver side has a bigger impact than the same amount on the gold side. Gold is also held by central banks in significant amounts and that has its own impacts.
TGR: Pan American is selling for less today than it was a year ago when the price of silver was higher. What is causing the distortion?
RB: Forward-looking investors bought in the $10 range with the expectation that the price of silver would go up.
TGR: So today's higher silver price was priced into the stock?
RB: Yes. Today a lot of people have taken money out of the equities because they fear perturbations in world economies that will drive down all metals.
The other factor is that Pan American had some unusual political exposure this year. For example, Peru. When Ollanta Humala was elected president, people thought he would be another Chavez and nationalize the mining industry, so they sold our stock. That didn't happen, but the stock took a hit anyway. We also have an enormous asset in Argentina, but it needs some political changes before its value becomes apparent. These things weigh on our share price.
I am optimistic about the price going forward because these concerns haven't been realized. We are taking advantage of the share price devaluation to buy back $150M of our stock. It is a great use of our capital. So, this market correction is a gift because it gives us a chance to increase the value-per-share for shareholders who want to keep their shares long term.
TGR: Are the same dynamics at play in copper?
RB: They call copper Dr. Copper because of its ability to reflect global economic conditions. In the last 50 years, it has had many cycles. The most recent bull trend is really driven by industrial demand from China. Copper is used in energy transmission, energy generation and, at the other end, all kinds of consumer goods. Cars use a huge amount of copper and electric cars use even more. Developing countries use an immense amount of copper to grow.
TGR: But if China experiences an economic slowdown, what does that do to copper demand?
RB: I have a different view of China. I don't believe the enormous ship of China has turned course. It may have hit a few waves but it still has a long way to go to improve living conditions for its people. I don't see growth stopping because there is a little bit more debt than it should have or it is acting a little bit more bellicose than it should. China will take its place as a world leader and remain an engine for economic growth.
TGR: Why aren't stock prices reflecting Chinese demand?
RB: China has been the single most important factor in the metals bull market of the last nine years for fundamental reasons. The recent problems in the stock market haven't been about China but because of the problems in the rest of the world. In early 2009, a lot of people were saying China's run is over. That was the best investment opportunity in my lifetime. That was when you wanted to back up the truck because everything was so oversold. A lot of people said it was the end of the world, the end of the bull market. It turned out metal prices bounced right back and they have been like that for the last couple of years and are just slightly off that peak now. Copper is still at prices that most mining companies just love. I'm taking the view that this is a great opportunity to be a buyer. It's the people who are contrarians and have the courage to buy when everyone else is selling who make the big money.
TGR: But this downturn is less about financial institutions collapsing than fears of a double recession. If Dr. Copper reflects economic growth, why are you still optimistic?
RB: I look at the whole world as a source of demand. Things are booming in Saudi Arabia, South America, India, parts of Asia. In all those places there is growth, which demands new infrastructure and that requires a lot of copper. Even though there is a slowdown in the U.S. and Europe, there is great growth elsewhere. Every day more people are born and more people want stuff. This is very supportive of long-term high prices. Nothing goes up forever in a straight line. Price corrections are absolutely normal and healthy.
TGR: Is this the same thing you are seeing in nickel?
RB: Nickel is less complicated. It has one use-stainless steel. You just have to look at demand for that and things look pretty good there. On the nickel supply side, it is changing radically. The cheap, easy-to-operate nickel mines are being mined out and being replaced by expensive-to-build and operate nickel mines. So you need high nickel prices to bring into production and sustain those mines. If nickel prices go down, those may be shut down, which will reduce supply and increase prices.
TGR: What is the magic number where nickel mining is no longer profitable?
RB: That might be $5-$6/pound on a global average, maybe more.
TGR: Lumina Copper Corp (LCC:TSX) and Anfield Nickel Corporation (ANF:TSX.V) are two metals companies you are involved in with an explore-and-sell business model. Mergers and acquisition activity has been off lately. Do you see that changing?
RB: I think there has been a lot of acquisition in the last year globally. A big deal was announced last week by a Chinese company for an African copper producer.
TGR: Is that the trend, that China will be the home of a lot of the acquirers?
RB: China has been the number one buyer for sure. It isn't just limited to the Chinese companies, however. In the last cycle it was English, American and Canadian companies. Now it's the developing countries: Indian and Korean companies are entering the space. They want to secure long-term metal supplies because they need them to secure supply for their manufacturing businesses. They are worried about buying on the open market and the prices going up, so they are taking action by buying assets in the ground. It also reduces their exposure to the U.S. dollar. I don't see that changing anytime soon.
TGR: You said you are an optimist and the proof might be your dedication to renewable energy.
RB: I'm doing that as much for love as money. I think it is an important legacy for my children to wean ourselves from fossil fuels. Oil and gas are great for making a lot of things, but it is a terrible waste to burn them. Alterra Power Corp. (AXY:TSX) started up in 2008, went public in 2009 and already has $1.1 billion in assets, all generating clean power, profitably.
TGR: Your strategy has been to make it bigger. You started with geothermal and added wind and run of river. Will you keep growing it?
RB: Even though I am disappointed in the stock market reaction the last couple of years, I am proud of our execution of the business plan. We have a wonderful team of experts, adequate capital and we are building a large alternative energy company that is profitable and sustainable and will live way beyond my lifetime. This is based on development of energy sources that are free: wind, heat and water. You just have to hook them up to a turbine. This takes a lot of money, but once they get going, they run essentially forever at very low cost.
Alterra is already a medium-sized alternative power company that will survive and prosper for a long time. We are working on how much bigger we can get and with what technology: wind, water or geothermal. Do we want to grow organically or do we want to buy other businesses on an accretive basis? It has to be a winning proposition for everyone. This is the ultimate long-term business.
TGR: Long term and steady, but without big jumps in price.
RB: It's the opposite extreme of mining where you have no control over your revenues. In this business, you fix the prices for the long term, 20-25 year contracts, so your revenues are steady and predictable. Banks love these long-term businesses. These are ultimately big dividend producers.
TGR: How long before it starts paying off?
RB: We are in a position to pay dividends today. But I think we can better reward our shareholders by growing. We might be there next year or sometime after that.
TGR: What are you most excited about?
RB: I am most excited about continuing to build Alterra Power into a bigger and better clean energy company. We can do this in any market, be it bear or bull. Bear markets aren't all bad. It is often easier and cheaper to build things in tough markets when other companies are stressed. Slower markets usually also mean lower capital costs. But I also like bull markets; it's always nice to see the share price go up.
I don't know what is going to happen next week or next month, but if we keep our heads down and execute on our business plan, we will build value.
TGR: We are at the When Money Dies conference that says fiat currencies will die. Since you are so tied to U.S. dollars, do you believe that and how do you deal with that?
RB: I am involved in a natural hedge against dollar devaluation-metals mining. As currencies weaken, metals prices go up. It's a good place to be today. And in alternative energy, once you have operating plants using wind, water or geothermal heat, you have long-term predictable revenues and no exposure to commodity prices. It's another great place to be today.
TGR: But if the dollar weakens, don't your operating costs go up as well?
RB: You have to hope that revenue increases faster than expenses and that is what has happened so far.
For the complete audio collection of the Casey Research/Sprott Inc. Summit When the Money Dies,click here.
Ross J. Beaty is a geologist and entrepreneur who currently serves as chairman and CEO of Alterra Power Corp. and Pan American Silver Corp. He also founded and divested a number of other public mineral resource companies. Born in Vancouver, Beaty has degrees from the Royal School of Mines, University of London, (M.Sc., Distinction in Mineral Exploration, 1975) and the University of British Columbia (LL.B. [Law] 1979 and B.Sc. [Honors Geology] 1974). Working in 50-plus different countries during the course of 37-plus years in the international minerals industry, he speaks English, French and Spanish, as well as some Russian, German and Italian.
Beaty is a past president of the Silver Institute in Washington, D.C., a fellow of the Geological Association of Canada and the Canadian Institute of Mining, recipient of the Institute's Past President's Memorial Medal, and a founder of the Pacific Mineral Museum in British Columbia. Beaty received the Association of Mineral Exploration of B.C.'s Colin Spence Award for excellence in global mineral exploration in 2007 and in 2008 the Mining Person of the Year award from the Mining Association of B.C. and the Ernst & Young, Natural Resources Entrepreneur of the Year award.
Want to read more exclusive Gold Report interviews like this? Sign up for our free e-newsletter, and you'll learn when new articles have been published. To see a list of recent interviews with industry analysts and commentators, visit our Exclusive Interviews page.
1) JT Long and Karen Roche of The Gold Report conducted this interview. They personally and/or their families own shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: None.
2) The following companies mentioned in the interview are sponsors of The Gold Report: None.
3) Ross Beaty: I personally and/or my family own shares of the following companies mentioned in this interview: Pan American Silver Corp., Alterra Power Corp., Keegan Resouces Inc. I personally and/or my family am paid by the following company mentioned in this interview: Pan American Silver Corp.
Streetwise - The Gold Report is Copyright © 2011 by Streetwise Reports LLC. All rights are reserved. Streetwise Reports LLC hereby grants an unrestricted license to use or disseminate this copyrighted material (i) only in whole (and always including this disclaimer), but (ii) never in part.
The Gold Report does not render general or specific investment advice and does not endorse or recommend the business, products, services or securities of any industry or company mentioned in this report.
From time to time, Streetwise Reports LLC and its directors, officers, employees or members of their families, as well as persons interviewed for articles on the site, may have a long or short position in securities mentioned and may make purchases and/or sales of those securities in the open market or otherwise.
Streetwise Reports LLC does not guarantee the accuracy or thoroughness of the information reported.
Streetwise Reports LLC receives a fee from companies that are listed on the home page in the In This Issue section. Their sponsor pages may be considered advertising for the purposes of 18 U.S.C. 1734.
Participating companies provide the logos used in The Gold Report. These logos are trademarks and are the property of the individual companies.
101 Second St., Suite 110
Petaluma, CA 94952