Comparing Players of Different Eras in Sports

 
on May 17 2012 2:13 PM
Comparing Players of Different Eras in Sports

Sports analysts often tend to compare players who have played in different eras throughout history. Whether it's the NBA with Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant or the NHL with Wayne Gretzky and Sidney Crosby, there are always comparisons.

In this article I will be focusing on how you can compare current players in the NBA and NHL to players of the past.

There are many differences that several NBA greats may not want to admit to. Technology has massively improved in the 21st century. Training techniques have developed as well and there is much more information available to the public. The internet didn't even exist back then! Now you can look up on Youtube to find out how you to increase your vertical and basketball skills. You could argue that in this era, the game is a lot more polished. If you were to look at a basketball game from 20 years ago, you would realize three things.

1. The game seemed a lot slower.

2. There were a lot more white players playing.

3.  They all wore short shorts.

In all seriousness though, I'm thankful that Michigan's fab five made longer shorts popular.

Do these points above mean that Wilt Chamberlin wouldn't dominate today's NBA like he did when he played? No. In my opinion he would still be a great player, but maybe not put up the same dominant numbers.

With the NHL there are similar differences in the sport of hockey. There are more advanced training techniques and there is better technology. More importantly there have been rule changes. Two line passing, goalie equipment sizes and numerous of other key changes. This has once again made for a more polished game.

I think that there are two ways that people often compare current players to past players.

1.   The characteristics and playing style of a current player to a past player. You often see this in draft analysts when up and coming players are compared to current or ex NBA'ers. This helps scouts categorize what type of player they will be.

2.   When people argue who's better or even sometimes who's worse.

Personally, the best way to determine the better player when looking at different eras is to look at one key aspect. How much that given player dominated their league in that certain point in history. This is why Michael Jordan and Wayne Gretzky will always go down as the best players in their respective sports.  Based on the way the NHL and NBA function today, it would be nearly impossible to break the majority of Wayne Gretzky's records. Michael Jordan's records are equally impressive and hard to break.

Generally as an avid sports fan, you thrive on watching history being made in front of your eyes. You want to be able to tell your grandkids that you saw Lebron James win his first NBA championship. You want to remember seeing Tom Brady break the touchdown record in a season. This is the reason why so many of us even watch sports. Comparing present events to past events will always happen; it's part of the essence of sports.

Share this article