'Too Big To Fail' Banks Doing Worse Than The Rest in Key Areas: New York Fed

Share this article

The 20-page report by the U.S. central bank branch, which contains data about the period leading up to the second quarter of 2012, was billed by the institution as providing a broader picture than the more comprehensive quarterly banking industry report published by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. The Fed report looks at bank-holding companies, and not just banks (which are all that the FDIC report examines).

"The distinction between the two concepts is important, because "around 30 percent of aggregate banking industry assets are held outside firms’ bank subsidiaries," the New York Fed said in a blog post announcing the report's release.

Even more important was the Fed's useful take on the momentum within the banking industry, in which it illustrated how general trends in capital reserve ratios and  leverage and loan book performance are affecting the largest banks in the country, comparing their performance to the sector as a whole.

The view from the top of the balance sheets of the seven largest bankholding companies -- JPMorgan Chase and Co. (NYSE: JPM), Bank of America Corp. (NYSE: BAC), Citigroup Inc. (NYSE: C), Wells Fargo and Company (NYSE: WFC), Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS), Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (NYSE: GS), and MetLife Inc. (NYSE:MET) -- reveal some distressing facts.

Compared to the rest of the banking industry, those companies are making proportionally fewer loans and deriving less interest income. The ratio of non-performing assets for those banks, again when compared to medium and small-size institutions, is noticeably high. Residential real estate, which is improving overall, appears to be a big problem for those financiers.

Perhaps most tellingly, loan growth at large banks has stalled, with other institutions driving nearly all of the spike in lending within the U.S. recently.

Not that large banks aren't making any money.

The six biggest banks -- that is, all the ones considered as the largest by the Fed with the exception of MetLife -- made $63 billion in profit during the first half of 2012, the highest amount earned since 2006. But a lot of those profits are coming from non-interest income (i.e., higher fees on services), cost-cutting initiatives, positive accounting tricks and other measures that improve the bottom line but are not sustainable.

Underneath, as the Fed report shows, things are not as happy as they would seem.

Since the global financial crisis, the ratio of interest income has dropped dramatically at large banks when compared to their smaller competitors -- a reflection of poor results in core loan-making businesses.

Since the global financial crisis, the ratio of interest income has dropped dramatically at large banks when compared to their smaller competitors -- a reflection of poor results in core loan-making businesses. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Part of the reason has been the divergence in the amount of non-performing loans. Big banks seem to have a larger number of those when compared to the industry as a whole.

Part of the reason has been the divergence in the amount of non-performing loans. Big banks seem to have a larger number of those when compared to the industry as a whole. Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

Real estate loans in particular have seen poorer rates of foreclosure at large institutions.

Real estate loans in particular have seen poorer rates of foreclosure at large institutions. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

And the divergence in the residential real estate loan market is uncanny.

And the divergence in the residential real estate loan market is uncanny. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

As a result loan-loss reserves have dwindled at large institutions. A

As a result loan-loss reserves have dwindled at large institutions. A "flip" in 2011 occurred as the momentum for this balance sheet item became negative for large banks while it was positive for the rest of the industry. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

The result: large banks are not increasing their lending. Nearly all increases in that category over the past few years come from small and medium-sized institutions.

The result: large banks are not increasing their lending. Nearly all increases in that category over the past few years come from small and medium-sized institutions. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

And to make up for those shortfalls, large institutions have been forced to deleverage more than the median trend.

And to make up for those shortfalls, large institutions have been forced to deleverage more than the median trend. Federal Reserve Bank of New York

More News from IBT MEDIA