U.S. stocks fell for a second straight session on Monday as investors ditched home builders and financials on fears lawmakers may let a federal home buyer tax credit expire, while commodity shares succumbed to pressure from the higher U.S. dollar.
Trading was choppy. Stocks initially started on firmer footing, with indexes up more than 1 percent shortly after the open, but the bounce quickly faded as the U.S. dollar rebounded and investors fretted about the financial sector's prospects.
The tax credit has become a hot button issue and Wall Street sold off after an incorrect media headline said research firm, ISI Group, had written the tax credit probably would not be extended when it expires November 30.
The research report, however, was similar to news on Friday that Senator Majority Leader Harry Reid wanted to phase out the tax credit over time, and not let it expire. Reid said on Monday the Senate could vote as soon as Tuesday to extend the tax break.
It's a tough sell now to Congress to say we need another extension of the home buyer tax credit when supposedly we are out of the recession, according to economists, and housing is doing well again, said Joe Saluzzi, co-manager of trading at Themis Trading in Chatham, New Jersey. If they are talking more of a phase-out than an extension, that certainly will hurt the market.
Without the home buyer credit, investors worry that the struggling housing market might lose a crucial incentive that has spurred hopes of stabilization in recent months.
The Dow Jones industrial average <.DJI> dropped 104.22 points, or 1.05 percent, to 9,867.96. The Standard & Poor's 500 Index <.SPX> shed 12.65 points, or 1.17 percent, to 1,066.95. The Nasdaq Composite Index <.IXIC> fell 12.62 points, or 0.59 percent, to 2,141.85.
The S&P 500 is now up 57.7 percent from the 12-year closing low of March 9, having slipped from its recovery peak when it was up 62.3 percent from that low.
Financials also came under pressure from the news that Dutch banking, insurance and asset management company ING
That plan might set a precedent for some of the U.S. institutions that received federal government bailout funds, said Marc Pado, U.S. market strategist at Cantor Fitzgerald & Co in San Francisco.
If the banks are going to focus on mainly repaying the government, they are not going to lend, they are going to cut back on mortgages, and make it even stricter to get a mortgage, he said. It's the domino effect and that hurts the home builders.
Among home builders' shares, luxury home builder Toll Brothers
The CBOE Volatility Index <.VIX> ended up 9.2 percent, its biggest one-day percentage gain in a month. During the session, the VIX rose as much as 11.6 percent, which marked its biggest intraday percentage jump in nearly two months.
The U.S. dollar rallied from a 14-month low against the euro as falling stock and commodity prices dampened risk appetite, prompting investors to lock in recent gains in other currencies.
The dollar's rise pressured commodity prices, which hurt shares of natural resource companies. Chevron Corp
On the bright side, RadioShack Corp
Volume was moderate on the New York Stock Exchange, with about 1.39 billion shares changing hands, below last year's estimated daily average of 1.49 billion. On the Nasdaq, about 2.34 billion shares traded, slightly above last year's daily average of 2.28 billion.
Declining stocks outnumbered advancing ones on the NYSE by a ratio of more than 3 to 1, while on the Nasdaq, more than two stocks fell for every one that rose.
(Editing by Jan Paschal)