(Deletes paragraph 13 of Jan. 19 story to reflect that Thomson Reuters I/B/E/S changed comparable EPS to $3.79 from $4.11. Error first appeared in UPDATE 5.)
NEW YORK - Goldman Sachs Group Inc posted a 53 percent decline in fourth-quarter profit as trading revenue tumbled, dashing hopes that the Wall Street bank had bucked a tough trading climate in debt markets.
Bond trading revenue, including commodities and currencies, slid 39 percent from the third quarter as worries about European sovereign debt and rising U.S. Treasury yields kept investors on the sidelines.
Things were just dead in December, though it's sure a lot more active in January, Chief Financial Officer David Viniar said on a conference call.
Profit fell for a third straight quarter, and revenue fell short of estimates, with year-over-year declines in investment banking and most other business segments. Viniar said Goldman's backlog of investment banking business fell from the third quarter, which may dampen revenue in the current quarter.
Goldman shares closed down $8.19, or 4.7 percent, at $166.49 on the New York Stock Exchange, their biggest one-day percentage decline since last April 30, Reuters data showed.
Results weighed on other stocks, as the Standard & Poor's financials index closed down 2.2 percent, while broader U.S. stock market indexes dropped more than 1 percent.
If Goldman Sachs can't show a strong performance, then good luck to anyone else trying, said Simon Maughan, an analyst at MF Global in London.
The results capped a year that has tested Goldman Chief Executive Lloyd Blankfein, and also tested the bank's reputation for having the smartest bankers on Wall Street.
Goldman has been criticized for activities such as its management of a private offering by social networking company Facebook Inc, and its marketing of a mortgage-related security that led it to pay $550 million to settle regulators' civil fraud allegations last July.
Despite the weakness, Goldman shares have held up far better than those of many rivals, and trade around where they were when the financial crisis exploded in September 2008.
Goldman said it would pay out nearly 40 percent of full-year revenue in the form of compensation and benefits, a higher percentage than in 2009, though 2010 profit fell 37 percent and revenue declined 13 percent. Compensation per employee dropped 14 percent to about $431,000.
Quarterly net income after payment of preferred stock dividends fell to $2.23 billion, or $3.79 per share, from $4.79 billion, or $8.20 per share, a year earlier. Net revenue declined 10 percent to $8.64 billion.
On that basis, analysts on average expected profit of $3.76 per share on revenue of $9 billion.
It's a very difficult environment, said Keith Davis, an analyst at Farr, Miller & Washington, which owns Goldman stock. Absent what we saw from JPMorgan, the Goldman results wouldn't have been a surprise. JPMorgan raised the bar.
Blankfein said in a statement the bank is seeing signs of growth and more economic activity in 2011.
JPMorgan Chase & Co last Friday posted a mere 8 percent drop in quarterly fixed-income revenue. In contrast, Citigroup Inc on Tuesday posted a 58 percent drop.
Shares of Morgan Stanley and Bank of America Corp, which report results later this week, fell 3.5 percent and 4.2 percent, respectively, on Wednesday.
PAYOUT RATIO RISES
Results so far have spurred questions about how much money banks can make from bond trading in 2011. Fixed income accounted for about half of revenue before the credit crisis, but is expected to account for less in the future.
Quarterly investment banking revenue fell 10 percent from a year ago to $1.51 billion, though Goldman reclaimed from Morgan Stanley its crown as the top mergers and acquisitions adviser.
Viniar declined to discuss Goldman's dealings with Facebook, including its decision this week to limit a private offering of Facebook stock to non-U.S. investors.
Goldman made more money from trading for its own account. Revenue from investing and lending rose 11 percent from the third quarter, accounting for 23 percent of total net revenue.
Viniar said new regulatory rules might limit some of the bank's investing and lending activities.
The bank said its average value at risk, or the amount it could lose from one day of trading with a 95 percent confidence level, was $120 million, down 1 percent from the third quarter and 34 percent lower than a year earlier.
For all of 2010, Goldman's profit after preferred stock dividends fell to $7.71 billion, or $13.18 per share, from $12.19 billion, or $22.13. Net revenue fell to $39.16 billion from $45.17 billion.
Long known for generous compensation, Goldman said total pay and benefits fell 5 percent to $15.38 billion in 2010.
As a percentage of revenue, pay and benefits totaled 39.3 percent in 2010, up from 35.8 percent in 2009 but more than 6 percentage points below the average in the last decade.
Goldman ended 2010 with 35,700 employees, up from 32,500 a year earlier, and Viniar said staffing could grow by a mid- to high-single-digit percentage in 2011. (Additional reporting by Maria Aspan, Ben Berkowitz, Christian Plumb, Jonathan Spicer and Dan Wilchins in New York and Steven Slater in London; editing by John Wallace, Martin Howell, Gary Hill)