About 240 guests were in attendance and the bride wore an ivory Vera Wang gown, while the groom donned the Coast Guard dress uniform. They received a sword salute as they exited the church.
Guests included Rhode Island Governor Lincoln D. Chafee and his wife, Stephanie; and Catherine T. Taylor, director of the state Department of Elderly Affairs and her husband, lawyer Robert K. Taylor, as well as Olympic champions Brian Boitano, Dick Button and Dorothy Hamill.
News of the wedding remained particularly mum until Kwan was spotted with her bridesmaid leaving the Hope Club just after 3:30 p.m. on Saturday, according to the Providence Journal.
Uniformed police officers stood guard outside as they made their way to the church across the street.
According to People magazine, the bride cried as she was escorted down the aisle by her father, Danny Kwan.
The Olympic bronze medalist and nine-time U.S. national figure skating champion incorporated the song “Fields of Gold” that she famously skated to at the 2002 Salt Lake City Games, into her ceremony. She and Pell also shared self-written vows.
Still overcome with emotion, the couple reportedly kissed just short of usual direction by the minister.
“A few minutes later, the minister said, 'And for their second first kiss as Mr. and Mrs. Clay Pell,' and everyone laughed,” a guest told People.
An hour later, the bride and groom emerged from their ceremony among their guests who held giant sparklers in celebration. They headed back to the Hope Club for their reception.
"You could feel the love Michelle and Clay have for each other," one guest said. "They are truly a perfect match."
Kwan told People magazine in September that she always knew Pell was “the one.”
“I never was one who believed in love at first sight, but I have to admit it happened for us. I felt there was a magnetic connection between us. I thought he was the one from the beginning,” she said.
Kwan, before she retired, was the most decorated figure skater in American history. She now works as a senior adviser for public diplomacy and public affairs. Her husband is the director for strategic planning on the National Security staff at the White House.