Carly started with “Feeling Good” by Nina Simone and had the judges wrapped around her fingers before the music even came on.
Music producer L.A. Reid sat back in his seat and yelled, “What?” at hearing the girl's voice for the first time.
Carly effortlessly sang the classic ballad and gave her own twist to the song, which she picked out herself to sing for “The X Factor” judges.
She exuded confidence, and when she showed up to the boot camp audition, she didn’t disappoint.
This time around she went for a modern hit, “Pumped Up Kicks,” by Foster The People, that she sang with another “X Factor” contestant Beatrice Miller.
Beatrice Miller is also 13 years old and similarly got four yeses from the judges.
After their rendition of “Pumped Up Kicks” tweeters took to the Twitterverse to write how impressed they were with the young girls, but most of the praise went to Sonenclar.
@ImJustMeBri said, “I think Carly Rose is my favorite #xfactor”
@IceeQueen wrote “Carly Rose Sonenclar killed it!! #XFactorUSA”
@brittanyadelle tweeted, “Carly Rose is my favorite and I hope she wins X Factor.”
@RickPickle posted, “i cant get over how amazing carly rose is wow #xfactor”
@rayato thought, “Carly Rose vs Beatrice Miller: 13-yr-old singing Pumped Up Kicks lol. Carly killed it but I actually like Beatrice. #xfactor”
@ash_johnsonn shared, “carly rose has more talent in her left hand than i have in my entire body”
@SamanthaMx3 believes, “CARLY ROSE SONECLAR YOU DID ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. OMG I CANNOT TAKE THIS MUCH TALENT.”
@CyerraCass wrote, “The way carly rose soneclar made my heart drop #iwanttobuyhermusic”
Check out some rare footage of Sonenclar singing an acousitc version of "Pumped Up Kicks" with her brother: