The International Whaling Commission's annual meeting ended with pro-whaling nations walking out to block a vote on establishing a whale sanctuary, exposing the Orca-sized gulf underlying the whaling talks.
Japan, Norway Iceland continue to hunt whales on a large commercial scale, defying a 1986 moratorium banning commerical whaling. That discrepancy was a source of tension throughout, with Japan accusing Australia of allowing activists to sabotage Japanese whaling votes and Iceland, Norway and Japan leaving the meeting after a Latin American bloc sought a vote on establishing a sanctuary in the South Atlantic.
The Commission has been regularly criticized for its ineffectiveness, something reaffirmed by the scant progress made at this year's meeting -- BBC correspondent Richard Black, in his seventh year covering the conference, described the body as ill-fit for purpose, archaic, hopelessly riven and suited only for the scrapyard. He was not alone in his frustration.
You can only conclude that this Commission -- which, despite a moratorium, does not have a mandate to stop the large-scale hunting still going on -- is genuinely dysfunctional, said Frederic Briand, head of Monaco's delegation, told Agence France-Presse. Since the moratorium was put in place in 1986, more than 33,000 whales have been killed.
Still, environmentalists and pro-conservation groups noted that rules intended to protect whales have been largely successful despite some resistance.
Continue Reading Below
The majority of whale stocks are moving in the right direction, often at a pace of five to 10 percent per year, said French scientist Vincent Ridoux, a member of the Commission's scientific committee.