Affordable Housing Needs to Cast a Wider Net To Better Serve Communities
Isaac Quesada on Unsplash

When I was 11, my family — me, three siblings and my mom — moved out of an unaffordable rental home into a tent, located in the woods on the edge of town. We stayed there through the summer until November, when it started to snow.

We weren't the stereotypical picture of homelessness. We had once lived in our own home. Mom was a second-generation college graduate. Dad was a Vietnam vet who had struggled with baggage he carried into the marriage. They divorced and Dad moved out of state, able to dodge child support because that's how it was in the 1980s. Mom worked two to three jobs at once, doing the best she could to earn a living.

Another single mom in town found out about our situation. She had a converted garage apartment and offered it to my mom to rent. Her generosity spared us from the worst of winter. Our homelessness was temporary because someone saw a problem and offered a solution.

I went on to build a career in the affordable housing industry and have spent nearly 30 years in it. Many people tend to think about affordable housing as something that serves a particular segment of the population. Yes, it provides homes for low-income individuals and families, seniors living on fixed incomes, and people with disabilities. But it also serves individuals and families who have steady jobs and still struggle to keep up with rising rents and home prices.

And here's something I don't think gets said enough: It's not only the people who live in affordable housing who benefit from it.

I was reminded of that during a conversation with Greta Harris, president and CEO of Better Housing Coalition in Richmond, Va. Greta said she once toured one of Better Housing Coalition's communities with the CEO of a major Richmond employer. He asked how many of his employees would qualify to live there. Probably none, she explained, because their incomes were too high.

But then she challenged him to think about the people who make his employees' comfortable lives possible. Who takes care of their children while they're at work? Who looks after their aging parents? Who serves their meals at their favorite neighborhood restaurant? Who performs at the community theater they enjoy on weekends?

Those people are part of the workforce that makes Richmond a place where his employees want to live. And many of them depend on affordable housing to remain in that community.

Communities That Price People Out of Housing Negate Job Creation

Then consider this story from Jared Jones, co-founder of Middle Housing Partners, about the principal and guidance counselor at his daughter's school. Both grew up in the community, attended the same school where they now work, and earn nearly identical salaries. But their housing situations couldn't be more different. The principal owns a home just a block from the school. The guidance counselor moved away and later returned to the area and could no longer afford to live in the community where she grew up.

Now she commutes 45 minutes each way. Think about what that means. Not just the extra hour and a half she spends in her car every day, but the opportunities she may miss to attend a school concert, stay for an after-school activity, or simply be present in the community she's helping to shape.

That's one of the problems we are seeing in communities all across the country. Teachers, nurses, first responders, and so many others are finding themselves priced out of the very places that depend on their work. Many of them earn too much for traditional housing assistance, but not enough to afford the houses available to them.

We spend a lot of time talking about economic development, attracting businesses, creating jobs, and building communities where people want to live. But how often do we talk about whether the people filling those jobs can actually afford to live there? Because you can bring all the jobs you want to a community, but if the people you need to fill them can't afford to live nearby, you've only solved half the problem.

And this isn't just an issue for people looking for housing. It's an issue for employers trying to recruit and retain good employees. It's an issue for schools, hospitals, restaurants, and small businesses. It's an issue for anyone who wants their community to thrive.

The Problem Underneath the Problem

Many times, my company has been brought in by a housing authority to fix operational backlogs. Given the high level of regulations and compliance in affordable housing, it's one of the most common problems.

However, there are many times you can build solutions without knowing the exact problem underneath the problem. It's crucial to keep in mind that you're only seeing the tip of the iceberg. We see this with the people we help move into housing. When they call in asking how to get a voucher, that's the obvious surface request. Our team has to intuitively ask themselves, "What is really being asked here? What's hiding at the core of this request?"

The real request is what's not being verbalized:

• How long do I have to keep living in my car?

• How can I get my kids out of this terrible school district?

• How do I help my grandmother find housing she can afford on her fixed income?

When people are living with that level of housing insecurity, the logistics question is never a random request. The full story may not come out, but the well-seasoned team knows what is happening in the background. They can navigate the request because they know there is more to it.

Housing affordability isn't one problem with one solution and it isn't limited to one income bracket. We need housing options that reflect the full range of people who make a community work.

About Katie Goar

Katie Goar is president of Quadel, a consulting and training firm that has worked in the affordable housing industry for more than 50 years. A passionate advocate for expanding access to safe, stable housing, she has nearly 30 years of experience in the field. She is a TEDx speaker, host of the "ChangeMakers" podcast in partnership with Forbes, and author of the Amazon #1 bestselling book AUDACITY: Go from Wannabe Leader to the Leader Others Wannabe. Goar has been recognized by Affordable Housing News Magazine as a Power Woman in 2023 and a Resilient Leader in 2024, by Indy Maven as a Woman to Watch in 2025, and by the Women's Affordable Housing Network (WAHN) as one of the 50 Over 50 Women of Influence in Affordable Housing in 2026. She earned a BA in political science/Spanish from Anderson University and an MPA in public administration with a focus on policy analysis from Indiana University.