Jared Kushner, Steve Witkoff and Volodymyr Zelenskyy
U.S. envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff join Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders in Berlin on Nov. 19, 2026, for talks on Ukraine's security guarantees. Getty Images

Russia rejected NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine Friday, directly challenging claims by U.S. President Donald Trump's envoy Jared Kushner that Moscow had become comfortable with Western security commitments modeled on the alliance's collective-defense provisions.

Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said any arrangement that effectively granted Ukraine partial NATO membership would be unacceptable, casting doubt on a central element of Washington's efforts to negotiate an end to the war.

Ryabkov's remarks came just a day after Kushner told European leaders in Berlin that American negotiators had made progress in persuading Russia to accept security guarantees resembling NATO's Article 5.

"We've gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept," Kushner said Thursday, referring to guarantees based on the alliance's mutual-defense commitments.

But Ryabkov rejected the suggestion Friday, saying even an arrangement that amounted to Ukraine's "quasi-membership" in NATO would cross a Russian red line.

Speaking to Russian state media, Ryabkov said Moscow would consider discussing security guarantees only after Kyiv accepted Russia's longstanding demand that Ukraine must never join NATO, according to Reuters.

His remarks exposed a significant disagreement over what protections Ukraine could receive after a potential ceasefire, even as the Trump administration seeks to advance negotiations with Moscow and Kyiv.

Under NATO's Article 5, an armed attack against one member is considered an attack against all, requiring allies to assist the country under attack. However, the provision does not automatically require every member to respond with military force.

An Article 5-style arrangement for Ukraine could offer similar security assurances without granting the country formal membership in the alliance.

Kushner, who attended Thursday's Berlin meeting alongside fellow U.S. envoy Steve Witkoff, said Trump was open to such guarantees but emphasized that any American commitment would have to serve U.S. interests and form part of a broader security agreement.

The talks brought together Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders seeking assurances that Russia would not be able to launch another invasion after a ceasefire.

A joint statement released by the German government outlined possible protections, including sustained military and financial assistance, a U.S.-led ceasefire monitoring mechanism and a European-led multinational force supported by Washington.

The proposed framework also contemplated legally binding commitments to take measures to restore peace and security in the event of another Russian attack.

Those commitments remain proposals rather than a finalized security agreement.

Zelenskyy has also questioned whether Washington and Kyiv share the same understanding of what an Article 5-style guarantee would mean in practice.

Speaking after the Berlin discussions, the Ukrainian president said he was uncertain whether the two countries had a common interpretation of the proposal and indicated that a credible postwar arrangement would require the presence of allied forces in Ukraine, according to Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.

That position creates another complication because Moscow has consistently opposed the deployment of Western military forces in Ukraine.

French President Emmanuel Macron, meanwhile, called for reopening the discussion about Ukraine's eventual membership in NATO, arguing that Russia's demands should not determine Kyiv's future security arrangements.

Ryabkov's response Friday followed Macron's remarks and underscored Moscow's continued opposition to any arrangement that could bring Ukraine closer to the Western military alliance.

Despite the disagreement, diplomatic contacts have not stopped.

Ryabkov confirmed that preparations were underway for a possible visit to Moscow by representatives of Britain, Germany and France.

Russian President Vladimir Putin said Thursday that Moscow had proposed receiving European envoys to clarify their positions before determining the format of further peace negotiations. The latest dispute follows renewed Russian attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure, including strikes that damaged three major bridges in Kyiv.