Bitcoin price decline
An illustration of Bitcoin, the world's largest cryptocurrency, as billions in withdrawals from U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs put renewed pressure on prices and raise questions about institutional investor demand. Getty Images

Bitcoin's latest sell-off has put billions of dollars in institutional investment under pressure, with U.S. spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds recording nearly $2.9 billion in net withdrawals this month and the cryptocurrency trading roughly 20% below an estimated entry price for a major wave of third-quarter ETF inflows.

Bitcoin was trading around $63,800 Thursday, after falling toward $62,000 earlier in the week. The cryptocurrency has struggled to regain momentum even as the selling has renewed questions about whether Wall Street's growing influence is changing the four-year market cycle that previously shaped Bitcoin's biggest rallies and declines.

U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs recorded $306.5 million in net outflows Wednesday, extending the selling to a second consecutive session, according to Farside Investors' ETF-flow data. The latest withdrawals brought November's net outflows to approximately $2.89 billion, despite a brief return to inflows earlier in the week.

"The four-year cycle was always more habit than law. It worked because enough people believed in it, and markets have a habit of punishing consensus," Mati Greenspan, founder of Quantum Economics, said in comments provided to International Business Times.

"This is the first cycle where Wall Street is a dominant player, and ETF money moves on interest rates and portfolio rebalancing, not on halving dates."

The latest ETF figures illustrate how quickly institutional demand has weakened.

BlackRock's iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT) accounted for $148.7 million of Wednesday's withdrawals, followed by Fidelity's FBTC with $69.3 million and Bitwise's BITB with $36.6 million. Grayscale's GBTC recorded $20.3 million in outflows, while ARK 21Shares' ARKB lost $19.3 million.

The selling followed $239.9 million in net withdrawals Tuesday, when BlackRock's fund alone accounted for $209.5 million. Monday had briefly interrupted the trend with approximately $7.9 million in inflows.

But the pressure extends beyond the latest trading sessions.

A Bitfinex Alpha analysis published Wednesday found that U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs attracted $6.36 billion in net inflows during the third quarter, with $5.76 billion, or approximately 91%, arriving between August 17 and September 25.

By weighting daily net ETF flows against Bitcoin's closing prices, Bitfinex estimated an average entry price of approximately $80,070 for inflows during that period.

At Thursday's price of roughly $63,800, Bitcoin was trading approximately 20% below that estimated level.

The figure is an analytical estimate rather than a verified purchase price for individual investors. ETF-flow data cannot establish which investors bought at particular prices, whether they subsequently sold or whether they continue holding their original positions.

Bitfinex also examined third-quarter institutional ownership filings, identifying increased holdings among wealth-management operations at major banks and several hedge funds.

The analysis found that Wells Fargo's reported IBIT holdings rose from approximately 24.4 million shares at the end of June to 49.58 million shares at the end of September. Bank of America also increased its reported position, while Brevan Howard and Millennium expanded their holdings.

Those filings offer a snapshot of institutional positions at the end of September, however, rather than a record of what those investors currently own.

Bitfinex estimated that $3.09 billion had flowed out of spot Bitcoin ETFs during the fourth quarter through November 17, equivalent to 49% of the preceding quarter's inflows.

Adding Wednesday's $306.5 million in withdrawals brings the fourth-quarter net outflow to approximately $3.4 billion, equivalent to slightly more than half the third-quarter inflow total.

That comparison measures changes in aggregate ETF flows. It does not mean half the investors who bought during the third quarter have sold their holdings.

Despite the recent withdrawals, the funds have accumulated approximately $54.16 billion in net inflows since U.S. spot Bitcoin ETFs began trading in January 2024, according to Farside's cumulative data.

That remaining investment is one reason Greenspan believes the latest selling may represent institutional risk reduction rather than a wholesale departure from Bitcoin.

"The recent outflows look like institutions trimming risk rather than walking away: they still hold the vast majority of what they've put in since launch," Greenspan said.

"I'd watch whether that bid comes back more than I'd watch the calendar."

Bitcoin's traditional four-year cycle has been closely associated with its halving events, which reduce the reward miners receive for validating transactions and slow the creation of new coins.

Previous cycles featured major price advances following halvings, followed by substantial market corrections. But the arrival of spot Bitcoin ETFs introduced a different source of demand, connecting cryptocurrency investment more closely to institutional portfolio allocations and broader financial conditions.

The latest downturn has also unfolded against a backdrop of uncertainty over Federal Reserve policy and volatility in technology stocks, both of which can influence investors' appetite for risk.

Bitfinex's analysis suggests the reduction in institutional exposure extends beyond ETFs.

Open interest in Bitcoin futures on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange declined from approximately 102,100 BTC on November 13 to 97,100 BTC by Wednesday, according to the exchange data examined by Bitfinex. That suggests some participants in the regulated futures market have also been reducing positions.

The firm identified $61,300 as an important technical support level, corresponding to the lower boundary of a trading range established during the summer.

Its analysts said a sustained move below that level, accompanied by ETF withdrawals exceeding $300 million a day, could bring Bitcoin's July low of $57,803 back into focus.

Conversely, three consecutive sessions of ETF inflows, stabilizing futures positions and improving on-chain indicators would strengthen the case that institutional selling was easing, Bitfinex said.

Not all market observers believe the recent weakness points toward a prolonged downturn.

Utkarsh Ahuja, founder and managing partner of Moon Pursuit Capital, argued in commentary shared with IBT that the sell-off may be creating opportunities for investors willing to tolerate further volatility.

"I see the current sell-off as an increasingly attractive buying opportunity. My view is that Bitcoin is approaching, or may already be establishing, a cyclical bottom," Ahuja said.

"Could Bitcoin briefly fall below $60,000? Absolutely. But I don't believe we need to revisit those levels to establish a bottom, nor do I expect a sustained move materially below the lows we saw in late June and early July,'' he added.

His assessment contrasts with Bitfinex's more cautious technical outlook, highlighting the uncertainty over whether the recent decline is approaching exhaustion or could develop into a deeper correction.

The next test for Bitcoin may therefore depend less on its historical halving calendar and more on whether institutional demand returns.

With billions withdrawn from ETFs, futures positioning weakening and the cryptocurrency trading substantially below the estimated entry level for recent ETF inflows, investors are watching for signs that the selling is slowing.

For Greenspan, the critical signal is whether Wall Street's appetite for Bitcoin returns, rather than whether the market follows the timetable of previous cycles.