Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux have yet to confirm that they got married Wednesday night, but all the buzz is about their alleged nuptials. According to reports, the two got hitched during an intimate ceremony at their Bel Air home. Seventy friends and family were said to be in attendance as the Hollywood A-listers said “I do” … but the catch is that the newlyweds threw off their guests with the guise that they were attending a surprise birthday party for Theroux!

Sources close to the pair revealed to People that Aniston invited pals like Ellen DeGeneres, Howard Stern and Chelsea Handler. Guests were led to believe that they would be celebrating Theroux’s 44th birthday, which falls on Monday, Aug. 10. The date also marks the third anniversary of Aniston and Theroux’s engagement.

Fans of the couple will have to stay tuned for a statement confirming the wedding, but in the meantime we’re looking back at some of the moments when the tabloids speculated that Jennifer Aniston and Justin Theroux took the plunge and got married. Check out the slideshow above.